Well, depends how much you can wait and what's your entry point... you'll be fine, you have mined your coins, he didn't, he bought them.
That's completely irrelevant.
That's like people at casino's betting big with their earlier winnings, losing it all and then stating it wasn't theirs to start with. Total bull shit.
Not sure if I understand good what you are trying to say, it happens sometimes as English is not my native language.
Goat will be pretty good if he just holds on loads of coins he mined, I strongly believe Bitcoin will be worth more in the future. If he doesn't sell anything or just small parts of it to support his lifestyle he'll still be fine. as he got his coins very cheap. His collection will be worth more or less during time but if he is happy with size of his collection and doesn't want to trade he'll be fine in long period.
I tried to explain to you that after you have the Bitcoins in your possession (or any investment for that matter) the entry point has become irrelevant. If I have 100 BTC and I received them all as a gift from Satoshi it's the same as when I bought them all at $266. At that point in time you have 100 BTC and can decide to either keep them or sell them but the origin of the Bitcoins is irrelevant.
Ah, well that's a serious bullshit

It is absolutely no irrelevant, we are still living in fiat world and invest fiat to get BTC, so if one had invested 250 000$ to buy 1000 coins at April 9th, he is in no way same situation as one who invested 5000$ to buy them sometime in 2011/12.
Actually, more I think about what I've just read more I think you are really not aware how stupid is that what you just wrote..
Meh, whatever..
I seriously advise you to think about it some more. This is a twist in most peoples thinking process which is really unprofitable to have (so fix it!). It is completely irrelevant. BTW if it makes it easier for you the same would be true for holding some shares of KO (Coca Cola) for instance. At the moment you have the shares you can make an investment decision (hold or sell). How the shares came in your possession should not hold any value in that decision (it is irrelevant i the rational decision making process).




